top of page
ALTERNATIVE CORNWALL -AN ANALYSIS


Devolution of income tax – an inherent problem
Summary The Prime Minister has suggested that local authorities could get a share of income tax receipts to use in their area. This proposal is promoted as a means of increased devolution giving local authorities more power over spending. An important and relevant question is how much funding could be derived from this source. Data from HMRC provides estimates of the income tax paid in each local authority. Using this data it is possible to calculate how much money could b
rpwills
7 hours ago3 min read


Cutting carbon emissions by reducing those of high earners
Summary High earners consume more energy and thereby create more greenhouse gas emissions. One way of reducing both would be to cut energy usage of the top earners and thereby carbon emissions. If emissions were capped at the average for all earners then those in the top four income deciles – 7 to 10 would see cuts in their output. High earners (10) would see the largest fall (58%), followed by 33% (9) and 20% (8). Overall emissions would be cut by 15%. Most people would
rpwills
4 days ago1 min read
Cutting energy and emissions by reducing outputs from high earners
Summary High earners consume more energy and thereby create more greenhouse gas emissions. One way of reducing both would be to cut energy usage of the top earners. If energy use were capped at the average for all earners then those in the top four income deciles would see cuts in their usage. High earners (10) would see the largest fall by 44% followed by 29% (9) and 18% (8). Overall energy use would be cut by 15%. Most people would not see any reductions at all. The
rpwills
5 days ago2 min read
The impact of a tax on house values on low income households
A tax on property values is deeply regressive. As lower income households would have greater difficulty in paying the tax they would be more likely to have to sell up which would be a very perverse result creating greater inequality in society. The analysis clearly indicates that any tax for local government services should be based on earnings levels. Introduction One of the many features of the United Kingdom is its strange persistence in looking to the past to provide
rpwills
Jul 303 min read


A fair tax system for local service provision
Introduction Much is made of inequalities in the Council tax system. Invariably it seems commentators, lobbyists and politicians focus on the fact that people with more valuable properties pay less than those in less valuable properties. Ostensibly this appears unfair yet this approach fails to recognise that what is actually important is what share of income is taken by council tax or any other value based tax. Another feature of British policy is that it invariably resu
rpwills
Jul 283 min read


Council tax – alternatives which should be non-starters
One of the many features of the United Kingdom is its strange persistence in looking to the past to provide policy. Perhaps not so odd when you consider that we still have a House of Lords for an upper chamber, which includes clerics! It still has an hereditary head of state with all the pomp and circumstance that entails. Traces of the past linger on in other ways particularly when it comes to taxes to fund local services and alternatives to the current system. The previ
rpwills
Jul 194 min read


What if everyone paid the same as council tax the English average?
Let us assume that all local authorities paid council tax with the same share as the England average. Namely 3.1% for the full tax and 4.6% for those on 0.75 of the full tax. This is an exercise designed to further display the current inequalities in council tax as a means of funding local government. Results As might be expected, where earnings are higher people would pay more and vice versa. Of those analysed Nottingham would see the biggest fall of 40%, followed by Corn
rpwills
Jul 142 min read


Council tax – built in inequalities
Much is made of inequalities in the Council tax system. Invariably it seems commentators, lobbyists and politicians focus on the fact that people with more valuable properties pay less than those in less valuable properties. Ostensibly this appears unfair yet this approach fails to recognise that what is actually important is what share of income is taken by council tax. Methodology This analysis attempts to address that issue. To do so council tax for Band D properties
rpwills
Jul 122 min read


Earnings and taxes
When discussing taxes on income lobbyists invariably refer to the marginal rate of tax for high earners implying that this is a significant level of taxation. But the correct figure to use is the total tax paid as a share of total income. This gives a more realistic number. Data on earnings and tax and National Insurance paid can be derived from the PayPrecisePremium UK Salary Tool. This allows for a comparison of different levels of earnings. It does of course not allo
rpwills
Jul 102 min read


The six housing myths
Various groups, free market lobby groups in particular, trot out a variety of assertions about housing issues. In essence they want more houses built as they live in a mythical world where supply and demand are the only shows in town. Lack of supply The lack of supply theory of why there are housing problems falls apart when any analysis of the evidence is performed. Its dominance reflects its simplicity ‘its supply and demand innit?’ and the pervasive influence of vocifer
rpwills
Jul 74 min read


Land uplift values – what are they?
Where land use is changed through the granting of planning permission from agricultural to residential development its value increases. The same applies when land changes use in an urban area. Critics of this uplift usually suggest that it is unearned and therefore should be captured through taxation and used by central or local government to fund local activities. Summary Where land use is changed through the granting of planning permission from agricultural to reside
rpwills
Jul 24 min read


Short-term lets
Main points From January to December 2025, there were 100,911,620 guest nights spent in short-term lets in the UK. There was an 11.5% increase in guest nights in 2025 from the previous 12-month period, January to December 2024 (90,507,070). Wales had the largest increase in guest nights among individual UK countries, rising by 17.4%, from 6,282,250 in 2024 to 7,374,780 in 2025. The North East saw the biggest percentage rise in guest nights, increasing by 22.2%, from 2,2
rpwills
Jun 303 min read
Assets and earnings – taxes and other policies
To conclude this series of posts on taxes on earnings and wealth some final thoughts and proposals. Introduction Analysis of the data on earnings and wealth reveal that it is neither possible nor sensible to treat them as separate issues. A silo approach is not appropriate as they are obviously closely linked. People with high earnings find it easier to accumulate assets than people on low earnings. It is debateable whether high earnings are appropriate anyway. People w
rpwills
Jun 244 min read


Assets and earnings – taxes and other policies
To conclude this series of posts on taxes on earnings and wealth some final thoughts and proposals. Introduction Analysis of the data on earnings and wealth reveal that it is neither possible nor sensible to treat them as separate issues. A silo approach is not appropriate as they are obviously closely linked. People with high earnings find it easier to accumulate assets than people on low earnings. It is debateable whether high earnings are appropriate anyway. People w
rpwills
Jun 244 min read


Taxing wealth/assets – some issues
One issue seemingly ignored by politicians and commentators alike is that different types of assets/wealth yield different levels of earnings if at all. The failure to understand this creates a situation where policies can be devised which create more problems than they solve. Summary There is a misconception that assets/wealth equate to affluence and that increases in value are in effect increases in income. But we could misquote the line from Anna Karenina in the novel
rpwills
Jun 224 min read


Energy use and carbon output by income – the summary
Summary Energy use is clearly linked to income, the higher someone’s income the higher the amount of energy consumed. The same applies to carbon output, the higher the income the higher the level of output. This is not surprising as carbon output is directly linked to energy use. Data Tonnes of carbon emitted range from 4.2 tonnes per annum for those in decile 1 to 22.3 tonnes for those in decile 10. Energy use ranges from 100 GJ for those in decile 1 to 279 GJ for those
rpwills
Jun 201 min read


Energy use by income – components of the transport sector
Energy use can be used as a proxy for greenhouse gas emissions. The more energy used the higher the level of emissions. Income deciles run from 1the lowest to 10 the highest. Summary Detailed analysis of the data reveals some interesting points. Energy use is clearly linked to income, the higher someone’s income the higher the amount of energy consumed. The average energy use is 155 gigajoules but those in deciles one to six use less than this while those in the top deci
rpwills
Jun 193 min read


Energy use by income – detailed disparities
Energy use can be used as a proxy for greenhouse gas emissions. The more energy used the higher the level of emissions. Income deciles run from 1-the lowest to 10 -the highest. Summary Detailed analysis of the data reveals some interesting points. Table 1 sets out energy use by the main components for each income decile. Energy use is clearly linked to income, the higher someone’s income the higher the amount of energy consumed. The average energy use is 155 gigajoules b
rpwills
Jun 174 min read


Energy use by income – the disparities
Energy use can be used as a proxy for greenhouse gas emissions. The more energy used the higher the level of emissions. "The analysis of data from 2019 highlights “significant inequalities” in energy use across the country. Those in the top 10% of incomes used nearly three times as much energy in a year as people in the bottom 30%. This was particularly true for transport. Car journeys and flights taken by the richest British people – especially “white, wealthy middle-age
rpwills
Jun 122 min read


The high earners – time for a change?
Recent research from the High Pay Centre outlines the gross inequalities in earnings between those at the top and the average worker. “Median CEO pay stood at £5.2 million and average at £6.2 million Median CEO pay increased 15% and average 19.75% from the year before for the same group of companies The median employee pay increase was 4.85%, while the average returned 6.23% The median CEO to 25th percentile employee ratio was 127:1, while the average was 144:1 The median
rpwills
Jun 112 min read
bottom of page